Theory 1: Yuber and Pesmerga are the same person (10%)

This is one of the earliest fan theories, dating back to discussions on old Suikoden forums in the late 1990s. The idea suggests that Yuber and Pesmerga are actually the same person, split across time or alternate realities. Their constant pursuit of one another would then symbolize a fractured identity.

Supporters of this theory point to their similar armor design and the mirrored darkness surrounding their presence. However, this theory struggles under the weight of evidence. The games explicitly portray them as separate entities, with dialogue where Pesmerga seeks Yuber directly. Unless one interprets this as a metaphor for self-pursuit, the text of the games does not support it.

Probability: 10%. A fascinating thought, but unlikely given in-game interactions.

Theory 2: Yuber and Pesmerga as literal Chaos and Order (25%)

Another popular belief is that Yuber embodies chaos while Pesmerga represents order. This draws heavily from mythological archetypes: eternal forces locked in conflict, each unable to exist without the other. Fans often link this theory to Yuber’s known possession of the Eightfold Rune, which aligns with destruction and chaos.

The strength of this theory is thematic. Suikoden is full of balance between dualities: war and peace, loyalty and betrayal, light and dark. Having Yuber and Pesmerga act as walking embodiments of these forces would fit neatly into that design.

The weakness lies in a lack of direct evidence. While Yuber’s chaotic nature is emphasized, Pesmerga is not explicitly tied to order beyond his pursuit of Yuber. The games never assign him a rune, leaving his motivations obscure.

Probability: 25%. Strong thematically, but weak in textual evidence.

Theory 3: Yuber and Pesmerga as cursed immortals (40%)

A middle-ground theory argues that both Yuber and Pesmerga are cursed beings, perhaps former humans twisted into something more. They are immortal, forever locked in a cycle of conflict. This would explain why they appear across centuries without signs of aging.

Fans often cite their unique armor designs and their seemingly inhuman presence as signs they are no longer mortal. The curse could even tie back to the Eightfold Rune or other True Runes, binding them to eternal conflict.

This idea has circulated widely in fan communities and resonates with Suikoden’s broader themes of destiny, cycles, and consequences of power. Still, it remains speculation without developer confirmation.

Probability: 40%. Plausible and compelling, but speculative.

Theory 4: Yuber as a True Rune servant, Pesmerga as his pursuer (65%)

The most widely accepted fan theory is that Yuber is a servant of a True Rune, most often linked to the Eightfold Rune. His destructive tendencies and lack of allegiance fit the profile of someone bound to such power. Pesmerga, then, would be his eternal pursuer, not as an embodiment of order but as someone cursed or chosen to hunt him.

This theory has strong support within the text. Yuber’s connections to the Eightfold Rune are mentioned in supplementary materials, while Pesmerga’s silence about his nature implies a deeper tie. It also explains why Pesmerga never appears outside of chasing Yuber: his entire existence may be defined by that pursuit.

Probability: 65%. Supported by lore, fan consensus, and thematic weight.